An Examination of Glass-fiber and Epoxy Interface Degradation in Printed Circuit Boards

Reading time ( words)

Multilayer organic laminates, which make up over 90% of the interconnecting substrates in electronics (standard FR-4 represents 85% of the substrates used for laminates), can develop a loss of electrical insulation resistance between two biased conductors due to conductive filament formation. The probability of conductive filament formation is a function of the temperature, moisture content, voltage bias, manufacturing quality and processes, materials, and other environmental conditions and physical factors.

With increases in design density and tighter spacing between conductors, the probability of failure due to conductive filament formation (CFF) in printed circuit board (PCB) electronic assemblies has increased. CFF is a failure observed within glass-reinforced epoxy PCB laminates caused by an electrochemical process involving the ionic transport of a metal through or across a non-metallic medium under the influence of an applied electric field [1 & 2]. The growth of the metallic filament is a function of temperature, humidity, voltage, laminate materials, manufacturing processes, and the geometry and spacing of the conductors [2]. The growth of these filaments can cause an abrupt loss of insulation resistance between the conductors under a DC voltage bias.

A statistical examination of field returns and root cause analysis performed at the Center for Advanced Life Cycle Engineering (CALCE) at the University of Maryland shows that failures in PCBs account for a significant percentage of field returns in electronic products and systems. Studies on CFF [2 & 3] have found that path formation in a PCB is often along the glass fiber to epoxy matrix interface (Figure 1).

Fig1-PECH-Jul2019.jpgFigure 1: Schematic describing CFF growth [3].

Delamination along the fiber-resin interface can occur as a result of stresses generated under thermal cycling due to coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) mismatch between the glass fiber (CTE = ~5.5 ppm/°C) and the epoxy resin (CTE = ~65 ppm/°C) (Figure 2). CFF can take place in the plated through-hole to plated through-hole (PTH-PTH), PTH-plane, and trace-trace geometries.

Figure 2: CFF growth path along the glass fiber and resin interface [3].

A two-step model was developed to explain the growth of conductive filaments at the resin-glass interface in PCBs [1 & 3] where degradation of the resin-glass interfacial bond first occurs, followed by an electrochemical reaction. According to Lando [2], the path required for the transportation of metal ions formed by the degradation of the resin-glass interfacial bond results from the mechanical release of stresses, poor glass treatment, hydrolysis of the silane glass finish, or stresses originating from moisture-induced swelling of the epoxy resin.

Fig2-PECH-Jul2019.jpgPath formation was reported to be independent of bias; however, humidity was identified as a contributing factor towards degradation. After path formation, the PCB is viewed as an electrochemical cell. In this cell, the copper conductors are the electrodes, the absorbed water is the electrolyte, and the driving potential for the electrochemistry is the operating or test potential of the circuit. The electrode reactions for the metal migration are:

At the anode:


Equation 1: EQ1-PECHT-Jul2019.JPG

Equation 2: EQ2-PECHT-Jul2019.JPG

At the cathode:

Equation 3:EQ3-PECHT-Jul2019.JPG

Pathway Formation in CFF

In PCBs, one manner in which the pathway between conductors is formed is through chemical hydrolysis of the silane glass finish or coupling agent. Past work has shown that the glass epoxy interface absorbs five to seven times more moisture than the bulk epoxy [5]. A common cross-linking agent used in FR-4 and many other epoxy-based laminated systems is dicyandiamide, or dicy. Dicy and glass surfaces are both hydrophilic. This combination of a hydrophilic surface and cross-linking agent is one of the factors responsible for the degradation of the glass fiber-epoxy resin interface due to hydrolysis. Williams [6] has shown that PCBs manufactured with non-dicy cross-linked epoxy resins are more resistance to CFF failures than PCBs manufactured with dicy cross-linked epoxy resins.

Organosilanes are bifunctional molecules that act as adhesion promoters, crosslink agents, and moisture scavengers in adhesive and sealant products [7]. Silane adhesion promoters act as molecular bridges between two chemically different materials and have been shown to dramatically improve the adhesion of polymeric resins to substrates such as glass, silica, alumina, or active metals.



Suggested Items

Flex Standards Update With Nick Koop

11/21/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
This month, I interviewed Nick Koop—director of flex technology at TTM Technologies, a veteran “flex guy” and instructor, and a leader of several IPC flex standards committees. Nick provides an update for the committees he’s involved with and discusses some of the challenges that he sees as more designers enter the world of flex.

Communication, Part 4: The Top 5 Causes of Engineering Delays

10/25/2019 | Steve Williams, The Right Approach Consulting LLC
In Part 4 of this series on how PCB fabricators and designers can better communicate, Bob Chandler from CA Design and Mark Thompson from Prototron Circuits address the top five causes of engineer delays.

Why Designers Need to Be at the SMTA Additive Electronics Conference

10/18/2019 | I-Connect007
In a recent interview, Kelly Dack and Tara Dunn (Omni PCB president and conference co-chair) discussed why designers need to attend the SMTA Additive Electronics Conference. Tara will also be attending and moderating a panel discussion at the conference.

Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.