Test and Inspection: Competitive Advantage and Cost of Doing Business

Reading time ( words)

In this interview, Charlie Capers of Zentech breaks down the changing requirements he’s seeing in test and inspection in the industry, and the growing importance of investing in testing for the future growth and success of your company.

Nolan Johnson: Charlie, test strategies seem to be all over the place.

Charlie Capers: Everybody does everything a little differently. It depends on your shop, your processes, the size of your shop, and the volume of the stuff you’re doing.

Johnson: What seems to be emerging is increased activity with the IPC J-standard; the shifts in how you approach ROSE testing, in addition to the customer-driven and OEM-driven demands that are changing for testing inspection regarding finished product. This is especially true for military and medical, which are starting to demand them.

Capers: Yes. Those are the top ones.

Johnson: As you move toward automation, isn’t there an increased need for test and inspection as a part of process control?

Capers: Yes. Maybe in larger shops, I would believe that. They go hand in hand. When you collect statistics on defects, you will start to see a trend that says, for example, we’ve got a lot of shorts and opens, meaning that our solder paste process is not tight. If you’re collecting statistics and really studying them, you will see trends in your processes. It’s part of the AS9100 too; you must collect your statistical data and review it every year.

Johnson: The trick is how to make it meaningful. Turning that not just into data but into intelligence and analysis seems to be where the gap is right now.

Capers: Yes. I would agree with that. You can collect data all day long. You can look at it and see you’re having issues, but unless you dig deep and ask why the issues in this particular area or with this particular defect are there, then all the data collection is kind of useless—but we do it anyway.

Johnson: From where you sit, have you seen any interesting work to turn that into usable intelligence?

Capers: We are currently using it for our internal records, and for our requirement of AS9100. If you dig deep, you could probably say something like, “Operator number 13 is screwing up left and right.” But is it a personnel issue? Is it a process issue? Is it a machine issue? What is it? At our size, we probably have the capability, but not the resources, to dig deep into that type of stuff.

Johnson: How do you get software tools to the smaller firms, which make up the bulk of the active companies in the U.S.?

Capers: The tools are not only the software; it’s capital equipment that helps ensures your processes are good. You could have every certification in the world: plaques, trophies, and all of this, for all the good work you do. But at the end of the day, it comes down to price, and everything else is expected. After putting money into AXI, ICT, AOI, flying probe and all those good things, it would be nice to be able to recoup that money. These days, though, it’s assumed that you will be doing all these processes.

Twenty years ago, maybe you could buy an AOI machine and be able to charge for that service. For ICT and flying probe test, we must charge because there’s a development cost involved with it. For flying probe testing, you must program the machine and debug the program to make sure it runs correctly. For ICT, of course, you must program the machine, but you also must procure a test fixture to put on that machine, a bed-of-nails test fixture. There are costs involved in that. In our little world, we must pass those through. For big production, I’m sure it’s just built into the price of “we’re going to build you a million boards and this is what it’s going to cost, and we’re going to guarantee everything.” It’s a different world.

To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the November 2021 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.


Suggested Items

Taiyo’s Brian Wojtkiewicz Discusses Flex, HDI and More

10/25/2022 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
Nolan Johnson spoke with Brian Wojtkiewicz at PCB West about Taiyo’s latest developments in solder mask technology. They discussed the company’s advances in flexible circuits, HDI, and much more. In particular, Brian discusses the importance of reliability in fabrication and assembly. "We’re always in the fabricators’ shops. I’m out in the field talking to them, helping the operators understand the process, and making things work better because then we don’t have issues down the road," he says.

Michael Carano: A Focus on Process Control, Part 2

09/28/2022 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
In this second half of our conversation, Michael Carano discusses some of the metrics that fabricators need to consider before investing in new processes, especially process control technologies, and some of the challenges board shops face updating brownfield sites.

EIPC Technical Snapshot: Novel Laser-based Manufacturing Processes in Automotive Electronics

09/22/2022 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
“Summer is over, now it's back to work!” This was the opening line of the invitation to the 18th EIPC Technical Snapshot webinar, Sept. 14, following the theme of advances in automotive electronics technology, introduced and moderated by EIPC President Alun Morgan. The first presentation, entitled "The fully printed smart component—combining additive manufacturing and sensor printing," came from Jonas Mertin, a thin-film processing specialist at the Fraunhofer Institute for Laser Technology.

Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.