Addressing the Gap in Process Performance

Reading time ( words)

The first steps in process improvement are to determine what the gap is and why it happens. Having a process is not sufficient; the process needs to be effective as well. For those responsible for creating and maintaining processes, the ultimate goal is to create a procedure that becomes self-perpetuating, that seeps into the fabric of the company’s culture. For better or worse, plenty of procedures do indeed become ingrained in company culture. How does one go about ensuring that company culture is loaded with effective processes that deliver a positive outcome? That is the question, to be sure. 

Analyzing Performance Problems, authored by Robert Mager and Peter Pipe, was published in 1970. Even 50 years later, it is still one of the most definitive—and digestible—books on the topic of skill gap analysis. Their model presents a thorough and effective method for troubleshooting performance problems. 

According to Pipe and Mager, first identify the performance problem. To do so, make the key metrics:

  • Measurable
  • Observable
  • Performance-based 

Armed with the metrics, the next questions are critical to the analysis: 

  • Is it worth solving?
  • Can we apply fast fixes?
  • Are the consequences appropriate?
  • Is there skill deficiency?
  • Are there other causes?
  • Which solutions are the best? 

This analysis process is captured in the flowchart for Mager and Pipe’s model.

While this model might seem almost simplistic, my personal experience is that the power of the model comes from the simplicity. This model is not attempting to determine the specific fix; that is a separate scope. Instead, Mager and Pipe are merely attempting to perform the triage, to identify the nature of the breakdown in performance. Once the root cause of the breakdown is understood, the type of resolution can be determined. How exactly that resolution is implemented, of course, is often highly situationally dependent. There may be more than one solution, in fact. And in terms of the current challenges in upskilling, is this 50-year-old method still meaningful? 

To read this entire article, which appeared in the April 2022 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.


Suggested Items

Classes and Meetings Under Way at IPC APEX EXPO

01/23/2023 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
IPC APEX EXPO 2023 doesn’t officially kick off until Tuesday, but there’s plenty of action going on here at the San Diego Convention Center. Booths are sprouting up on the show floor, and exhibitors are starting to arrive. Upstairs, committee meetings have been taking place all weekend; the IPC-J-STD-001 and IPC-A-610 Joint Task Group, and IPC-A-600 and IPC-6012 Joint Task Group meetings, were abuzz with activity. The Professional Development classes began on Sunday, covering everything from design through assembly processes, flex and rigid-flex, and technologies of the future.

Preventing De-wetting Defects In Immersion Tin Soldering

01/04/2023 | Britta Schafsteller, Atotech
Immersion tin is well accepted as a high-reliability final finish in the industry. Due to its excellent corrosion resistance, it exhibits major market shares, particularly in the automotive industry. During the soldering process, an intermetallic compound (IMC) is formed between copper and tin. One remaining concern in the industry is the potential impact of the IMC on the solderability of the final finish. In this article, typical failure modes in soldering immersion tin are described and correlated to potential root causes for the defects.

ICT Christmas Seminar 2022: The Caliber of a ‘World Cup’ Event

12/13/2022 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
Regardless of the potential distraction of the international football match between England and Wales in the World Cup competition, an enthusiastic crowd of PCB fans gathered in Meriden UK for the Institute of Circuit Technology Christmas Seminar, an eagerly-awaited networking opportunity that included a face-to-face industry welcome event and an outstanding technical programme. Guest speakers highlighted new technology in selective solder nozzles, flexible circuits, industry cooperation, and a greener future by recycling PCBs.

Copyright © 2023 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.