Technica Heats Up ROI Discussion

Reading time ( words)

The I-Connect007 Editorial Team speaks with Technica’s Frank Medina, Ed Carrigan, and Jason Perry about trending hotspots that provide the PCB fabricator a high return on investment (ROI). A theme that carries throughout the conversation is that traditional methods for calculating ROI are being replaced by models that include more qualitative factors.  

Nolan Johnson: Frank and Jason, where do you see the ROI hotspots in manufacturing right now? 

Frank Medina: One is solder mask equipment; another area is automation and material handling.

Jason Perry: I think there are several more areas. A lot of effort has been put into the inner layer and outer layer departments. People are moving toward upgrading the back end of the process. We’re seeing more demand for solder mask improvement and technology, direct write type of technology, and inkjet applications.

Reducing process steps, improving throughput, and improving time to market—getting product through the shop faster always equals higher dollars and lower costs. There’s a drive toward that on the back end, including automation to reduce labor costs as those costs continue to increase. We’re seeing demand to automate repetitive tasks the operators would normally be doing. The goal is to repurpose operators to more important areas, instead of just feeding lines or moving product, and let automation fill the void. 

Inkjet Solder Mask
It looks like the technology on inkjet solder mask is emerging into its own. Would you detail the steps that get removed from the process when you move to inkjet solder mask?

Jason_Perry_250.jpgPerry: You willstill do a direct write like you would with a direct imaging machine. The advantage now is you have no coating process.

The first step that’s removed is the coating of the solder mask application: any equipment or manual operation that is used to screen print, flood coat panels, or even spray coat panels. That process is quite inefficient because there’s a lot of process steps involved and wasted solder mask. With inkjet applications, we’re printing everything that we’re using, so there’s little to no waste. You can print the mask where you want, and not have to flood coat an entire panel.

That would be the first advantage. Another is reduction of VOCs because you have a lot of them in the conventional solder mask process, during the coating application; with inkjet, we’re eliminating that element of the process. It’s a big advantage as the industry moves toward being as green as possible, in specified regions. 

Direct Imaging
Barry Matties: 
Direct imaging is one technology that always seemed to offer a great ROI, but with a heavy investment. Is that a good ROI? What are the trends? Are more people looking for it, or is the market where it needs to be?

Perry: There’s been a definite industry shift toward direct imaging. Most of the shops now have some form of direct imaging machinery and there are more players in the market. There are still a small handful of shops who don’t have it, though. 

The drive for direct imaging (DI) has now shifted into the solder mask area for improved throughput and quality. The initial effort was for fabricators to use DI in the inner layer area because that is where they could realize the most cost savings impact, and then the technology was adopted in the outer layer imaging area. Now with the introduction of high-powered LEDs to image the solder mask, the new DI machines are delivering improved throughput, along with high resolution. Eventually, I think the move to inkjet solder mask will be a market shift in the near future as the equipment matures. 

Medina: The DI primary imaging equipment being purchased today isn’t as much about ROI as it is about the capability of the equipment to image finer and finer lines. The mSAP and other semi-additive processes are driving this need. We’re seeing more customers trying to image 0.001" and less.

But in regard to the evolution of this technology, as customers with DI start to upgrade to the new technology, the older models will become available and that will allow the smaller shops to get into DI at a much lower price through the used equipment market. 

There is no doubt the market continues to grow the use of DI equipment, but the next step is where inkjet comes in. As that technology evolves, it creates other opportunities for that type of technology to direct write, basically putting the resist just where you want it—rather than coat an entire panel and then remove what we don’t want. That’s a huge cost savings.

To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the May 2022 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.


Suggested Items

EIPC Summer Conference 2022: Day 1 Review

06/28/2022 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
At last, a live EIPC conference and this time in the Swedish city of Örebro, “where history and contemporary culture converge,” a pleasant and convenient location for an event that included a privileged visit to the Ericsson facility in Kumla. Around 100 delegates made the journey and the Örebro Scandic Grand Hotel was an excellent conference venue for the June 14-15 conference.

PCB Plating Still Comes Down to Physics

06/21/2022 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
We asked columnist Michael Carano to discuss the latest innovations in plating equipment and chemicals, as well as some of the drivers in this segment, and the biggest challenges and opportunities he sees in plating today. As Michael points out, despite all of the technological advances in this industry, process engineers still need a solid understanding of Faraday’s Law and Ohm’s Law to successfully plate PCBs.

Review: Institute of Circuit Technology 2022 Annual Symposium

06/15/2022 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
The British Motor Museum in Warwickshire, housing the world's largest collection of historic British cars, was venue for the 2022 Annual Symposium of the Institute of Circuit Technology on June 8, which attracted a substantial gathering of manufacturers and suppliers from the UK printed circuit industry. ICT chair Emma Hudson reflected upon lessons learned during the pandemic lock-down and how the industry has successfully adapted to circumstances. She commented that the UK’s PCB fabricators are extremely busy, as she introduced an outstanding conference programme including a keynote from the incomparable Happy Holden.

Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.