-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- pcb007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueThe Growing Industry
In this issue of PCB007 Magazine, we talk with leading economic experts, advocacy specialists in Washington, D.C., and PCB company leadership to get a well-rounded picture of what’s happening in the industry today. Don’t miss it.
The Sustainability Issue
Sustainability is one of the most widely used terms in business today, especially for electronics and manufacturing but what does it mean to you? We explore the environmental, business, and economic impacts.
The Fabricator’s Guide to IPC APEX EXPO
This issue previews many of the important events taking place at this year's show and highlights some changes and opportunities. So, buckle up. We are counting down to IPC APEX EXPO 2024.
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - pcb007 Magazine
A Scientific Response to Mr. Laminate Tells All
November 29, 2016 | Mark Goodwin and Bill Wang, Ventec International GroupEstimated reading time: 3 minutes
We read with interest Doug Sober’s recent Mr. Laminate Tells All column, The Certification of IPC-4101D Polyimide Base Materials: Buyer Beware.
The article raises interesting questions about the IPC 4101 classification system, primarily, how is a pure resin defined?
For thermosetting materials, the “resin system” includes at least a resin and a curing system, which can take many forms—can this be defined as pure?
“Purity” is a term generally applied to single compounds, especially in inorganic chemistry. To broadly apply this term to complex organic resin systems, which may contain multiple curing chemistries, inert and active fillers, and flame retardant components, is stretching the term beyond the breaking point.
Let us consider materials classified under IPC 4101/126 for example. The specification sheet states the following:
The primary resin system is listed as “Epoxy,” with a secondary of multifunctional epoxy or modified epoxy or non-epoxy (max. wt. 5%). However, for base materials’ manufacturers to meet the performance requirements of lead-free FR-4 and high decomposition temperature, it has been standard practice for base materials manufacturers to replace the previously common dicyandiamide curing element with a phenolic resin in /126 materials. The phenolic resin element is typically present in double-digit weight percentage proportions; these products are openly referred to as “phenolic cured epoxies.” If the argument about purity of resins were applied in the same way as in the polyimide example, then all manufacturers of /126 materials should be declared as having a secondary resin system outside of the specification requirements, and would therefore be non-compliant.
The only argument that allows base materials manufacturers to claim /126 compliance with such a high percentage of non-compliant secondary resins relates to the nature of the organic molecule. The argument is that many species may be used in the formulation, but in the final reacted state there is one molecule, which had epoxy functionality prior to curing (by definition, the presence of an epoxy functional group), and can therefore be correctly classed as an epoxy resin. To quote the article, “there is only one big molecule with the largest portion being the polyimide functionality. So it is a pure polyimide at that point. That argument does not hold any water…” We can just as easily replace the term “polyimide” with “epoxy” and we have the statement “there is only one big molecule with the largest portion being the epoxy functionality. So it is a pure epoxy at that point. That argument does not hold any water…” By inference, the author must also support the argument to disbar /126 materials that use a phenolic curing element, which is most, if not all of them.
Polyimide is, by definition, a polymer that contains imide groups. Polyimide resins form a family of chemistries, aliphatic or aromatic; they may be thermoplastic or form part of a thermosetting system and may or may not include flame retardant components. Using the same arguments above, for epoxy, the final reacted state is one molecule that contains a polymer that contained a functional group consisting of two acyl groups bound to nitrogen (an imide). It is just the same argument for /126 epoxies above; what is true for /126 must also be true for /40 /41.
To reinforce this distinction one should also not forget that in the final condition, no functional epoxy or imide groups exist at all as they will have all reacted as part of the crosslinking process. It is truly “one big molecule.”
Far from “using their own rules for substitutions” and saying “you (IPC) cannot stop us,” the laminators concerned (of which Ventec is just one) are applying a consistent and scientifically correct approach to the formulation of both polyimide and epoxy resin systems. And if a “special case” is being argued for /40/41 materials that somehow does not apply to /126 materials, then the buyer must truly beware of using the IPC 4101 slash sheet classification system at all.
Mark Goodwin is CCO, EMEA & Europe with Ventec International Group.
Bill Wang is technical director with Ventec International Group.
Suggested Items
Real Time with... IPC APEX EXPO 2024: Exploring IPC's PCB Design Courses with Kris Moyer
04/18/2024 | Real Time with...IPC APEX EXPOGuest Editor Kelly Dack and IPC instructor Kris Moyer discuss IPC's PCB design training and education offerings. They delve into course topics such as design fundamentals, mil/aero, rigid-flex, RF design, and advanced design concepts. They also highlight material selection for high-speed design, thermal management, and dissipation techniques. The interview wraps up with details about how to access these courses online.
IPC Bestows Posthumous Hall of Fame Award to Industry Icon Michael Ford
04/18/2024 | IPCIPC honored the late Michael Ford, Aegis Software, for his extraordinary contributions to the global electronics manufacturing industry with the IPC Raymond E. Pritchard Hall of Fame Award at IPC APEX EXPO 2024. IPC’s most prestigious honor, the Hall of Fame Award is given to individuals who have provided exceptional service and advancement to IPC and the electronics industry. Ford, an industry leader and valued IPC volunteer, died suddenly in January 2024.
Two Industry Rising Stars Recognized at IPC APEX EXPO 2024
04/17/2024 | IPCTwo of the industry’s best and brightest were presented with an IPC Rising Star Award at IPC APEX EXPO 2024 in recognition of their leadership roles and support of IPC standards, education, advocacy, and solutions to industry challenges. Award recipients were Naim Kapadia and Michael Schleicher.
Two Long-time IPC Volunteers Receive Dieter Bergman IPC Fellowship Award
04/17/2024 | IPCThe Dieter Bergman IPC Fellowship award was presented to two IPC volunteers at IPC APEX EXPO 2024. The award recipients have fostered a collaborative spirit, made significant contributions to standards development, and have consistently demonstrated a commitment to global standardization efforts. Tiberiu Baranyi and Zhiman Chen were chosen as award recipients as they embody the work ethic and spirit of the late Dieter Bergman, an industry pioneer and icon. As part of the award, they bestowed Dieter Bergman Memorial Scholarships to the university or college of their choice.
Real Time with... IPC APEX EXPO 2024: MYCRONIC's Evolution and New Solutions
04/17/2024 | Real Time with...IPC APEX EXPOHenry Crandall interviews Kevin Clue, the vice president of global sales for MYCRONIC's High Flex division. They discuss the company's evolution, emphasizing its strong customer relationships and its role as a versatile, turnkey solution provider. Kevin unveils new solutions launched at IPC APEX EXPO, including an AI-integrated inspection system and the A40 pick-and-place platform. The conversation also touches on the increased use of AI and deep learning.